Little Miss Innocent: Passion. Poison. Prison.

In 2017 when Kaitlyn Conley, a polite and well-liked young woman from upstate New York was found guilty of killing Mary Yoder, her ex-boyfriend’s mother, the local community was in shock. Now the victim’s family, the investigators and attorneys involved in Conley’s trial, and Conley herself are telling their sides of the story for the first time since her conviction.